ADA disability definitions
“This is kind of hard for me to talk about,” Harvey Pruitt said to HR manager Conwell Farnsworth.
“Don’t feel obliged,” Conwell said. “But I’ll listen if you want to talk.”
“Well, it’s this way,” Harvey said. “You know I have diabetes. I used to be able to manage it, but now….” He broke off uncomfortably.
“It’s getting worse?” Conwell said to encourage him to continue.
“Yes,” Harvey said. “I’ve got ulcers on both my feet. My sleep isn’t good. And also my … sex drive. I, um, need injections to, well, perform.”
“I appreciate you leveling with me,” Conwell said. “What would you like me to do?”
Delayed ADA Compliance?
“To start with, I need some help,” Harvey said. “My job requires me to be on my feet most of the shift, and like I told you, I’ve got trouble with my feet. I could use an assistant, or somebody to spell me.”
“That could be costly,” Conwell said. “We’ll look into it, though. Let me get back to you.”
Conwell didn’t act on Harvey’s request until two months later, when Harvey produced a note from his doctor saying he should be allowed to sit down at least half the time. After receiving the note, Conwell and Harvey’s supervisor worked out a new shift schedule that gave Harvey the help he had asked for.
By this time, though, Harvey was angry about the delay. He placed an ADA lawsuit, claiming the company didn’t accommodate him in a timely way.
Harvey said he was disabled in part because of his foot problems, and in part because of his sexual dysfunction.
Did he win the lawsuit?
No, Harvey didn’t win. The court said he didn’t prove he was disabled.
First, Harvey didn’t have a disability walking or standing. He just couldn’t stand for a full shift.
As for his reduced ability to perform sexually, the court said this wasn’t a disability under the ADA regulations either.
The decision might have been different if Harvey had a sexual problem that significantly limited his ability to reproduce. Reproduction, the court said, is a “major life activity,” and an impairment preventing it may be considered a disability under ADA guidelines. But Harvey was able to have sex, with a medical assist.
Infrequent isn’t a disability
Over the 15 years since the Americans with Disabilities Act was passed, the courts have recognized a number of “major life activities” that employees can cite as the basis of various disabilities. Reproduction is among these activities, but not sexual performance as such.
Employees whose thinking is colored by Viagra ads may consider themselves disabled because they don’t have sex as often as they used to. But a mere reduction in frequency or potency isn’t enough to win an ADA lawsuit.
Cite: Scheerer v. Potter, No. 05-2338, 7th Cir., 4/10/06. Fictionalized for dramatic effect.
Subscribe to HR Info Center
Get the latest research on workplace learning with weekly posts delivered to your inbox