Be able to justify your employee performance reviews
  • Blog post

Be able to justify your employee performance reviews

Make sure managers can justify their reasons for different employee performance reviews to comparable employees

We’d all like to think every aspect of our employee performance reviews, including bonuses, is free of bias of any kind. But a new study shows that even with a well documented system of employee performance evaluation, there’s a danger minorities will get short-changed when bonuses are handed out.


The study, by a professor at MIT’s Sloan School of Management, found that African-American managerial employees received bonuses 2.4% lower than those awarded comparable white men. Meantime, comparable Asian- Americans’ bonuses were 2.9% lower. (Also, comparable women’s bonuses were 2.1% lower.) The study looked at 9,000 exempt and nonexempt managers at a U.S. company whose identity wasn’t disclosed.


The problem, according to the study’s author, may have been that while employee performance reviews were fair, bias unconsciously crept in at a second stage – when higher management awarded bonuses based on the evaluations. If your organization breaks reviews and compensation decisions into separate pieces – as many compensation experts advise you to do – you may want to selfcheck the back end of your process.

Best bet: Ask managers who award raises and bonuses to document and justify any variances in what they give comparable employees.

Source: 2008-castilla.php

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Get a demo of all our training features

Connect with an expert for a one-on-one demonstration of how Rapid Learning can help develop your team.