Veteran HR people and managers are aware of some of the traps an interviewer can step into – like leaning toward people who share your interests, or favoring the physically attractive candidate.
But how about the “best of a bad lot” trap? That one can spring when:
- You’re in a hurry to fill a job, and
- The candidates you’ve interviewed so far are all worse than mediocre.
Now, if a candidate who’s even semi-competent walks into your office, you may see her as a winner, because you’re comparing her – perhaps unconsciously – to a bunch of losers.
Big mistake. Just because this person is better than lousy doesn’t mean she can do the job.
To avoid this trap and see more clearly, you can:
- Ask yourself: Would I hire this person if she were the only candidate I’d seen?
- Get a second opinion. Another interviewer, who hasn’t seen the bad candidates, will have a sharper view of the only slightly better one.
Source: “The Everything HR Kit,” by Putzier and Baker.
Subscribe to the Leadership Blog
Get the latest research on workplace learning with weekly posts delivered to your inbox